Effective interviewing is a critical skill for any hiring manager. It's how you move beyond a resume to find the best talent, build your team, and strengthen your company's brand.

Interview Process Structure: Keep it Lean

For the best candidate experience and a faster process, where possible aim for a maximum of 3 interview stages, including the initial recruiter screen. A streamlined process respects the candidate's time and keeps them engaged.

  • Stage 1: Recruiter Screen: The recruiter assesses core skills, motivation, and cultural fit. This is a crucial filter that ensures you only meet with qualified candidates.

  • Stage 2: Hiring Manager Interview: You, as the hiring manager, conduct a deeper dive into the candidate’s skills and experience. This is your chance to assess their technical and behavioral fit for your team.

  • Stage 3: Team/Panel Interview: The candidate meets with key team members or a small panel. This allows for a final check on collaboration skills and team fit.

Role level recommendations

  • Entry-level roles: a screening call followed by 1 additional stage.

  • Mid-senior level roles: a screening call followed by max 2 additional stages

  • Executive-level roles: an additional presentation-style interview can be included.

Process guidelines

Before the Interview: Prepare Thoroughly  

Review the Role and CV

  • Revisit the Job Description: Clearly understand the essential skills, responsibilities, and qualifications needed. This ensures you're assessing every candidate against the same criteria.

  • Analyze the Resume: Review the candidate’s resume and cover letter. Look for patterns, career progression, and specific achievements. Identify any gaps or areas that require clarification.

Create a Structured Interview Plan 

  • Develop a Scorecard: Create an interview scorecard with key competencies you will evaluate. This helps you rate each candidate objectively and avoid "gut feelings.". Use the template on Pinpoint as your starting point. 

  • Prepare Your Questions: Create a list of pre-determined questions. For consistency and fairness, ask every candidate the same core questions.

    • Behavioral Questions: These are based on the premise that past behavior predicts future performance. Ask candidates to describe specific situations using the STAR method (Situation, Task, Action, Result). For example, "Tell me about a time you had to handle a difficult stakeholder."

    • Situational Questions: These explore how a candidate would handle a hypothetical challenge. For example, "If you started this role tomorrow, what would be your top priority in the first 30 days?"

  • Schedule a Realistic Timeline: Plan your interview stages to be efficient and respectful of the candidate's time. Aim for no more than three stages, including the initial recruiter screen, to avoid delays.

Set the Stage 

Communicate with the Recruiter: Align on the interview plan, candidate's background, and what you need to assess.

  • Prepare Your Environment: Ensure you have a quiet, distraction-free space. If it's a video interview, check your lighting, audio, and background.

  • Review Your Selling Points: Be ready to talk passionately about the role, your team, and the company culture. Remember, top candidates are also interviewing you.

During the Interview: Engage and Assess  

  • Leverage Gemini: Utilize Gemini to transcribe and summarize your interview calls. This allows you to focus fully on the conversation, knowing that key details and a full transcript will be captured automatically.

  • Start with an Introduction: Begin with a brief welcome and outline the interview agenda. This sets the candidate at ease and shows you value their time.

  • Ask Strategic Questions: Move beyond basic questions. Use behavioral questions (e.g., "Tell me about a time when...") and situational questions (e.g., "How would you handle...?") to understand past performance and predict future behavior.

  • Listen Actively: Your goal is to learn. Follow the 80/20 rule: the candidate should be talking 80% of the time, and you should be listening 20%. Take detailed notes to help you recall specifics later.

  • Sell the Opportunity: Remember, a top candidate is also interviewing you. Be ready to talk passionately about the role, the team, and the company culture to get them excited.

After the Interview: Follow Up and Decide

  • Provide Timely Feedback: Give your recruiter feedback within 48 hours. This keeps the process moving and shows respect for the candidate.

  • Evaluate Objectively: Use your Gemini notes and the interview scorecards to assess the candidate against the defined criteria. Avoid making a decision based on "gut feeling."

  • Communicate the Next Steps: End the interview by clearly explaining what will happen next and the expected timeline. This shows professionalism and manages candidate expectations.

Interview formats:

By questions style

  • Behavioral Interviews: This is the most common format. It's based on the idea that past behavior predicts future performance. Ask candidates to describe specific situations from their past using the STAR method (Situation, Task, Action, Result). This gives you real-world examples of their skills in action.

  • Situational Interviews: These interviews focus on "what if?" scenarios. You present a hypothetical situation and ask how the candidate would respond. This assesses their problem-solving skills and critical thinking in a context relevant to the role.

Formats

  • One-on-One: A single interviewer meets with a single candidate. This format allows for a more personal conversation and can help you build a deeper connection with the candidate.

  • Panel Interview: You and other key stakeholders interview the candidate at the same time. This is an efficient way to get multiple perspectives at once and can help reduce individual bias.

  • Technical Interviews: Common for technical and engineering roles, these interviews evaluate a candidate's specific technical knowledge and problem-solving abilities. This can involve coding challenges, system design questions, or asking them to work through a technical problem on a whiteboard.

Adding a presentation to your interview process can be highly effective, especially for roles that require strong communication, strategic thinking, or public speaking.

  • Case Study Presentation: Give the candidate a business problem a few days in advance. They present their analysis and proposed solution. This is great for roles in consulting, product management, or strategy.

  • "Teach Us Something" Presentation: Ask the candidate to teach the interviewers about a topic they are passionate about or an area they are an expert in. This assesses their ability to educate and engage an audience.

  • Portfolio/Project Walkthrough: Common for designers and developers, this involves the candidate walking you through a past project they led. They explain their role, the challenges they faced, and the outcomes.

By choosing the right interview format, you can get the most accurate and relevant information to find the perfect person for your team.

Tips for Effective Panel Interviews

Panel interviews are a powerful tool for comprehensive candidate assessment and reducing individual bias. To make them truly effective, clear coordination and thoughtful execution are key.

1. Diverse Panels Are Essential

  • Broaden Perspectives: Ensure your panel includes individuals from diverse backgrounds, departments, and seniority levels. This provides varied perspectives on a candidate's skills, fit, and potential.

  • Reduce Bias: A diverse panel inherently helps to mitigate unconscious biases that can occur with single interviewers, leading to fairer and more objective decisions.

2. Coordinate and Prepare as a Team

  • Pre-Meet/Align: Before the interview, the entire panel must meet to align on the role's requirements, the interview plan, and the specific areas each panelist will cover.

  • Assign Questions/Topics: Clearly assign specific questions or topics to each panelist to avoid duplication. This ensures all critical areas are covered efficiently without overwhelming the candidate.

  • Share Previous Feedback: Ensure all panelists have access to the candidate's resume and any prior interview notes (e.g., recruiter screen feedback). This helps them tailor their questions and avoid asking for information already provided.

3. During the Panel Interview

  • Introduce Clearly: Start by introducing all panel members and their roles, and briefly explain the interview structure to the candidate.

  • Collaborative Listening: Encourage all panelists to listen actively, even when not asking questions. Take notes individually.

  • Facilitate Smoothly: Designate a lead interviewer to guide the conversation, manage time, and ensure all panelists get a chance to ask their questions.

4. Post-Interview Debrief

  • Structured Feedback: Conduct a debrief immediately after the interview (or as soon as possible). Each panelist should provide structured feedback based on the agreed-upon criteria and individual notes.

  • Consensus Decision: Facilitate a discussion to reach a collective hiring decision, focusing on evidence from the interview rather than individual "gut feelings."

Maintaining confidentiality:

Best practices

  • Limit Sharing: Only discuss candidate information with those directly involved in the hiring process.

  • Secure Documents: Manage resumes/CVs and interview notes securely, using Pinpoint. 

  • Be Mindful of Disclosure: Avoid sharing proprietary company information or confidential details with candidates or unauthorized staff.

  • Follow Policy: Always adhere to your company's data privacy guidelines

Why it's critical

  • Protects Business Strategy: Keeps future plans and projects secure from competitors.

  • Ensures Candidate Privacy: Safeguards sensitive personal information like salary and career history.

  • Maintains a Fair Process: Prevents outside influence and ensures candidates are evaluated on merit alone.

Can’t find what you are looking for? Contact us via People Team Support ticket.